Carolina Academic Press

Welcome to CAP Law

CAP Law Carolina Academic Press


Judgment View Table of Contents and Introductory Material


What Law Judges Can Learn from Sports Officiating and Art Criticism

by William D. Popkin

2017 $30.00 172 pp paper

Tags: Statutory Interpretation

Available on Kindle  Available on Kindle

Available on VitalSource

In Federalist No. 78, Alexander Hamilton tells us that judges have “merely” judgment but does not explain what judgment means. This book provides that explanation. It compares judgment across a range of activities—consumer choices, religion, sports officiating, art and food criticism, and law—with the goal of better understanding legal judgment. After exploring these various modes of comparison, the book concludes that law judging is fundamentally discretionary and uncertain. It then falls to the legal profession to explain to the public, without undermining respect for law, why this is so. In this way, not unlike our perception of the uncertainties that confront sports officials or that pervade scientific research, the public will come to appreciate the struggles that law judges encounter when making judgments.

700 Kent St, Durham NC 27701 • (919) 489-7486; Fax (919) 493-5668
Home | About Us | Comp Copy Information | Contact Us | Order Status | Returns Policy | Accessibility | Privacy Policy
© CAP 2020